Search for Pets Plus and you get a mix. Some results are pet stores. Others are a pet insurance plan. A few are a national franchise.
This guide clears it up. You will learn what each one offers, which pet supplies and services you can find, and which questions to ask before you spend.
What Is Pets Plus? Three Names, One Search
Pets Plus Pet Stores
Several independent pet stores use the name Pets Plus. Pets Plus Natural serves Pennsylvania and New Jersey. It says it has run since 1988 and focuses on natural and holistic pet food. Pets Plus California lists eight stores and offers curbside service. Pets Plus Lubbock in Texas sells live pets, pet food, feeder insects, and feeder rodents.
Pets Plus Us Pet Insurance
Pets Plus Us is not a store. It is a pet insurance and wellness plan. It is run separately from the shops above. Most searches like “Is Pets Plus legit?” and “How do I cancel Pets Plus Us?” are about this plan.
Pets Plus vs. Pet Supplies Plus
Pet Supplies Plus is a different brand. It is a national pet retail franchise. In December 2025, it and Wag N’ Wash became an independent company, separate from Franchise Group.
| Name | What it is | Model |
| Pets Plus (stores) | Local pet shops | Independent |
| Pets Plus Us | Pet insurance plan | Insurance company |
| Pet Supplies Plus | National pet retailer | Franchise |
Pets Plus Pet Supplies: What You Can Buy

Dog Supplies and Dog Food
A typical pet supplies store stocks dry, wet, freeze-dried, frozen, and raw dog food. Pets Plus Natural lists brands such as Orijen, Acana, Fromm, Annamaet, NutriSource, and Verus. Pets Plus California lists Orijen, Zignature, NutriSource, and Taste of the Wild. You will also find treats, toys, and WoofBones chews.
Cat Supplies
Cat food comes in the same formats as dog food. Shops also carry cat toys, treats, and litter. Cat ownership is rising. The American Pet Products Association (APPA) reports it grew 5% in 2025.
Small Animal, Bird, Fish, and Reptile Supplies
Most Pets Plus stores also serve small animals, birds, fish, and reptiles. Brands include Oxbow for small animals, Kaytee for birds, and Zoo Med for reptiles. Reptile owners often need feeder insects and feeder rodents. Pets Plus Lubbock lists both.
Pet Gates, Crates, and Safety Gear
Safety gear keeps pets out of trouble. Pet gates, crates, pens, ramps, and strollers are the common picks. Carlson Pet Products calls itself the #1 brand of pet gates in the U.S. Its Gate Selector quiz helps you match a gate to your pet and your home.
Pets Plus Services: Grooming, Self-Wash, and Pickup

Read Also: Super Pets: Meet the Heroes and Their Amazing Powers
Pet Grooming and Dog Self-Wash Stations
Pets Plus Natural offers pet grooming and dog self-wash stations. A self-wash station lets you bathe a dog without soaking in your own bathroom. It is handy for muddy paws, big dogs, and shedding season.
Curbside Pickup and Loyalty Rewards
Curbside pickup lets you order and collect without leaving your car. Pets Plus California and Pets Plus Natural both offer it. Pets Plus Natural also runs a Paw Points rewards program. Pets Plus Lubbock posts monthly specials.
Natural Pet Food and Supplements: What to Know
How to Read a Pet Food Label
Ingredients are listed by weight. Look for a “complete and balanced” statement from AAFCO. It shows the food meets set nutrient levels for your pet’s life stage. Check the first few ingredients. A named protein, such as chicken or salmon, should lead.
Grain-Free, Raw, and Freeze-Dried Food
Grain-free food skips wheat, corn, and rice. Freeze-dried food has water removed. Raw food is uncooked meat-based food. Vets have raised questions about some grain-free diets and heart health. Ask your vet before you switch.
Pet Supplements and Taurine
Taurine is an amino acid. Some brands, like Doggy Supps, sell it as a dog supplement. These products are not meant to diagnose or treat disease. Add a supplement only after your veterinarian says it fits your pet.
Pets Plus Pet Insurance: How It Works

Waiting Periods and Pre-Existing Conditions
Most pet insurance plans have a waiting period. Treatment for a problem that began before or during that window may be denied.
Pre-existing conditions are usually excluded. Customer reviews of Pets Plus Us often mention disputes over these two rules.
How to Compare Pet Insurance Plans
Before you buy, compare these points:
- Reimbursement rate (for example, 70% or 90%)
- Annual deductible
- Yearly or lifetime limits
- Exclusions and age limits
- Renewal terms
Read the full policy first. Ask what happens when your pet turns senior.
How to Choose the Right Pets Plus Store Near You
Local Store vs. Big Box vs. Online
A local pet store often offers hands-on advice and small-batch brands. A big box store may offer more locations and lower prices on some items. Online shops add convenience. The pet market is big. APPA reports 95 million U.S. households own a pet. Spending hit $158 billion in 2025.
Seasonal Pet Care Tips
Holidays bring hazards. Chocolate, grapes, raisins, onions, and xylitol are dangerous for pets. Fall can also bring seasonal allergies. Watch for itching, licking, and red ears.
FAQs
Is Pets Plus legit?
The Pets Plus stores are real local businesses with addresses and phone numbers.
Pets Plus Us is not BBB accredited. Its BBB profile lists seven complaints in three years. Reviews are mixed, so read the policy before you buy.
Is Pets Plus a franchise?
The independent Pets Plus stores are locally run. They are not part of a franchise.
Pet Supplies Plus is a different brand, and it is a franchise.
How do I cancel my Pets Plus Us membership?
Log in to your account and look for a managed subscription option. You can also contact Pets Plus Us customer service.
Is Pets Plus worth it?
For stores, it depends on what you need. Local advice, natural brands, grooming, and pickup are the main draws.
For insurance, it depends on your pet’s age and health, your budget, and the waiting period. Compare at least two plans first.
Conclusion
Pets Plus can mean a local pet store, an insurance plan, or a mix-up with a franchise. Know which one you need. For pet supplies and services, check your local store. For insurance, read the terms. When in doubt, ask your vet.
